My landlord never did a check-in inventory. Does that mean I automatically win the dispute?

Not automatically, but it puts you in a strong position. Without a documented starting condition, it is very difficult for a landlord to prove the damage was not already there, or that it was not simply the property ageing normally. Adjudicators give limited weight to damage claims that rely only on the property's condition at check-out, with nothing to compare it against.

The landlord's quote for repairs seems much higher than the item was worth. Can I challenge that?

Yes. Deductions have to be reasonable, and they have to account for the age and condition of the item before any damage — this is the betterment principle. A landlord cannot use your deposit to buy a brand-new replacement for an old or worn item. Ask for evidence of the item's age and challenge any quote that does not reflect depreciation.

Is normal wear and tear ever chargeable if the property looks quite worn at the end of a long tenancy?

No. The length of the tenancy actually works in your favour here — more wear is expected, and considered fair, over a longer tenancy. A property that looks used after several years of normal occupation is exactly what fair wear and tear looks like, not evidence of damage.

How long does the deposit dispute resolution process usually take?

It varies by scheme and the complexity of the evidence, but ADR is designed to be resolved in a matter of weeks once both sides have submitted their evidence, rather than the months a court claim can take. Check your specific scheme's website for its current process and timescales.

What if my landlord is deducting money without going through a scheme's dispute process at all?

If your deposit is protected, the landlord cannot simply keep part of it unilaterally once you dispute the deduction — the money in dispute should stay with the scheme until ADR concludes or you both agree. If a landlord has taken money without your agreement and without following the scheme process, or if your deposit was never protected at all, you can bring a money claim in the small claims court.

My landlord is lying about damage. What can I do?

Remember that the landlord has to prove the damage exists, that it was not there at the start, and that you caused it. Compare every item against the check-in inventory, gather your own photos and messages, and dispute the deduction in writing. If your deposit is protected, refer it to the scheme’s free dispute service, where an independent adjudicator decides on the evidence.

What should a letter to my landlord disputing damage claims say?

List each deduction you dispute and why — already on the check-in inventory, fair wear and tear, or no allowance for the item’s age. Ask for the inventory, dated photos and invoices behind each charge, say you do not agree, and say you will use the deposit scheme’s dispute service if it is not resolved.

Start My Claim

My Landlord Is Charging Me for Damage I Didn't Cause. How Do I Prove It?

Landlord charging for damage you didn't cause? They must prove it. How to dispute deductions, what to put in your letter, and how to chal…