Particulars of Claim: deposit disputes

A "deposit dispute" can mean very different things depending on context. The most common scenario is a tenancy deposit on an Assured Shorthold Tenancy under the Housing Act 1988 — these are subject to a strict statutory protection regime under sections 212–215 of the Housing Act 2004, with substantial penalties for non-compliance.

Particulars of Claim: deposit disputes

Three deposit scenarios

The second scenario is a holding or reservation deposit — money paid to secure a contract or property before completion, refundable on cancellation. Here the claim is purely contractual.

The third is a refundable retention — common in building and trade contracts where a percentage of the price is held back pending defects rectification or completion. Same contractual analysis applies, with the additional argument under the Housing Grants, Construction and Regeneration Act 1996 in some construction contexts.

The template below is structured so it can be adapted to any of these. The optional section 4A/4B is for tenancy deposit claims invoking the Housing Act 2004 penalty regime.

Annex the receipt, the tenancy agreement (if relevant), the LBA, and all correspondence about the deposit return.

The Housing Act 2004 penalty

Section 214 of the Housing Act 2004 entitles a tenant to apply to the court for an order requiring the landlord to repay the deposit and to pay an additional sum of between one and three times the deposit value as a statutory penalty.

Where to pitch the multiplier within that range is a matter of judicial discretion. The Court of Appeal in Okadigbo v Chan suggested the starting point is one times the deposit, increased for serious or repeated breaches. A landlord who never knew about the protection regime will typically face 1x. A serial professional landlord who deliberately failed to protect deposits across multiple properties will face 3x.

For a typical £1,200 deposit, the penalty range is therefore £1,200 to £3,600 — on top of the £1,200 deposit itself. This is what makes Housing Act claims worth pursuing even for relatively small deposits.

Want it filled in to your facts?

Start My Claim asks about the deposit, the agreement, and the failure to return it, then drafts a court-ready particulars of claim and LBA. £29 fixed.

Start your claim — £29 fixed →

Deposit disputes guide

Particulars: faulty goods