Indirect discrimination
A rule that looks neutral but lands harder on people who share a protected characteristic. The employer can defend it, but only by showing the rule was a proportionate way of achieving a legitimate aim.
What is the difference between direct and indirect discrimination?
Direct discrimination under section 13 of the Equality Act 2010 is treating someone worse because of a protected characteristic: not promoting a woman because she is a woman. Indirect discrimination under section 19 is applying a rule to everyone that, in practice, puts people with a protected characteristic at a particular disadvantage: requiring all staff to work full time, which disadvantages women as a group because they're more likely to have childcare responsibilities. Direct discrimination can almost never be justified; indirect discrimination can be, if the employer shows the rule is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim.
What is a provision, criterion or practice?
The Act doesn't define it, and tribunals read it broadly. It covers formal policies, contractual terms, selection criteria, shift patterns, dress codes, qualification requirements and informal but established ways of doing things. A one-off decision that isn't applied, and wouldn't be applied, to anyone else is less likely to count, but a one-off decision that reflects how the employer generally operates can.
Do I have to prove why the rule disadvantages my group?
No. In Essop v Home Office [2017] UKSC 27 the Supreme Court held that a claimant doesn't need to explain the reason why the provision, criterion or practice puts the group at a particular disadvantage; it's enough to show that it does, and that the claimant suffers that disadvantage too. Statistics, expert evidence or common knowledge can all be used, and the comparison is between the group that shares the characteristic and the group that does not, within the pool of people the rule affects.
Can I claim indirect discrimination if I don't have the protected characteristic myself?
Since 1 January 2024, yes. Section 19A, inserted by the Equality Act 2010 (Amendment) Regulations 2023, allows a claim by someone who doesn't share the protected characteristic but suffers substantively the same disadvantage as those who do. The example usually given is a man who can't comply with a full-time requirement for childcare reasons, where the requirement disadvantages women as a group.
How does an employer justify indirect discrimination?
By showing the rule is a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim. The aim must be real and lawful, such as operational needs, health and safety, or cost-effective service delivery, although cost alone isn't enough. Proportionality asks whether the rule is reasonably necessary to achieve that aim and whether a less discriminatory alternative would have done the job. The tribunal makes its own assessment; it does not simply defer to the employer.
What can a tribunal award for indirect discrimination?
Compensation for financial loss, such as lost earnings, and an award for injury to feelings in the Vento bands, which from 6 April 2026 run from £1,300 to £62,900. There's no statutory cap on discrimination compensation. The tribunal can also make a declaration and recommendations. Where the employer didn't intend to discriminate, section 124(4) and (5) require the tribunal to consider a declaration or recommendation before awarding compensation, but compensation remains available.
Section 19 breaks the claim into parts, and a tribunal takes them in order. Each must be made out before the next matters.
- 1 A provision, criterion or practice (PCP). The employer applies, or would apply, something to people who don't share the claimant's characteristic as well as to those who do. A full-time working requirement, a minimum height, a no-headwear rule, a requirement to be available at short notice.
- 2 Group disadvantage. The PCP puts, or would put, people who share the characteristic at a particular disadvantage compared with those who do not. The comparison is made within the pool of people the PCP affects.
- 3 Individual disadvantage. The PCP puts, or would put, the claimant at that same disadvantage. A claimant who happens to be unaffected can't claim on behalf of the group.
- 4 No justification. The employer can't show the PCP to be a proportionate means of achieving a legitimate aim. The burden here is on the employer.
Section 19(3) lists the characteristics to which indirect discrimination applies: age, disability, gender reassignment, marriage and civil partnership, race, religion or belief, sex and sexual orientation. Pregnancy and maternity aren't on the list; those cases are brought as direct discrimination under section 18 or, often, as indirect sex discrimination.
Proving disadvantage after Essop
For years employers argued that a claimant had to show why a PCP disadvantaged the group, and that if the reason was unconnected to the characteristic the claim failed. The Supreme Court rejected that in Essop. Civil servants from ethnic minority backgrounds, and older candidates, passed a core skills test at lower rates than others; nobody could say why. The court held that the claimants only needed to show the correlation between the characteristic and the disadvantage, and that they themselves suffered it. Why the PCP has that effect isn't an element of the claim.
The companion case, Naeem, shows the limit. A Muslim prison chaplain was paid less than Christian chaplains because the pay scale rewarded length of service and Muslim chaplains had on average joined more recently. The disadvantage was made out; the claim failed at the justification stage, because the service-related pay scale was held to be proportionate.
Evidence of group disadvantage can be statistical, drawn from the employer's own workforce data, or based on matters a tribunal can take as generally known, such as the fact that women still bear the greater share of childcare. Choosing the right pool matters: it should be all the people, with and without the characteristic, to whom the PCP applies.
Justification: legitimate aim and proportionality
Once the first three elements are shown, section 136 shifts the burden to the employer. It must identify a legitimate aim, which means a real business or operational objective that is itself lawful, and show that the PCP is a proportionate means of achieving it. Cost saving on its own isn't a legitimate aim, although cost can be weighed alongside other factors.
Proportionality is an objective balance between the discriminatory effect of the PCP and the employer's reasonable needs. The tribunal asks whether the PCP is appropriate and reasonably necessary, and whether a less discriminatory measure would have achieved the aim. An employer who never considered alternatives, or who can't explain why the rule had to be as strict as it was, will struggle. The band of reasonable responses test from unfair dismissal doesn't apply; the tribunal forms its own view.
Section 19A: same disadvantage without the characteristic
The Equality Act 2010 (Amendment) Regulations 2023 inserted section 19A with effect from 1 January 2024, preserving a point of EU case law that would otherwise have lapsed. It allows a claim by a person who doesn't share the relevant protected characteristic but who is put at substantively the same disadvantage as those who do. The textbook example is a single father refused part-time hours under a policy that disadvantages women. Before 2024 he had no indirect sex discrimination claim because he wasn't a woman; now he does, provided the policy disadvantages women as a group and he suffers the same disadvantage. The same justification defence applies.
Time limits and process
Under section 123 of the Equality Act 2010 a claim must be presented within six months, less one day, of the act complained of, for acts on or after 1 October 2026; the limit was three months for earlier acts. Conduct extending over a period is treated as done at the end of the period, which matters for a PCP that is applied continuously. The clock is paused by ACAS early conciliation, and the tribunal can extend time where it's just and equitable. Compensation includes financial loss and injury to feelings in the Vento bands, currently £1,300 to £12,600 (lower), £12,600 to £37,700 (middle) and £37,700 to £62,900 (upper), with no statutory cap.
A logistics firm introduces a requirement that all warehouse supervisors work a rotating shift pattern including two 6am starts a week. A supervisor who is a single mother can't arrange childcare before 7.30am and is moved to a lower-paid non-supervisory role.
Rotating shifts with 6am starts
Protected characteristic
Women more likely to have primary childcare
Individual disadvantage
Demoted; £4,800 a year less
Supervisor cover for early deliveries
Proportionality question
Could a fixed early shift for a volunteer have covered it?
The tribunal accepts that early cover is a legitimate aim but finds the firm never considered allocating the 6am starts to supervisors who wanted them. The PCP isn't proportionate. The claimant recovers her lost earnings to the hearing date, future loss for a period, and an injury to feelings award in the lower Vento band.
Direct discrimination
Protected characteristics
Equality Act 2010, Part 2, Chapter 2
Equality Act 2010 (Amendment) Regulations 2023 (SI 2023/1425)
Essop v Home Office [2017] UKSC 27
EHRC Employment Statutory Code of Practice
Indirect Discrimination — Employment Tribunal Glossary
What indirect discrimination is under section 19 of the Equality Act 2010, the four elements, the Essop ruling, section 19A same-disadvantage claims, justification and remedies.