Counterclaim
A claim the defendant brings back against the claimant inside the same case. It has its own fee, its own deadlines and its own judgment, and it can be worth more than the claim it answers.
Do I have to pay a court fee to make a counterclaim?
Yes. A counterclaim for money is charged at the same rate as issuing a claim for that amount, using the bands in the EX50 fee schedule, so a £3,000 counterclaim costs the same to bring as a £3,000 claim. If you qualify for help with fees you can apply for remission in the usual way. If the original claim settles or is withdrawn and only the counterclaim continues, the hearing fee becomes payable by the defendant who brought it.
Do I need the court's permission to counterclaim?
Not if you file the counterclaim with your defence. Rule 20.4(2) of the Civil Procedure Rules lets a defendant counterclaim against the claimant without permission at that stage. If you want to counterclaim later, or against someone who isn't already a party, you need to apply to the court for permission or for that person to be added.
Does the claimant have to respond to my counterclaim?
Yes. A counterclaim is treated as a claim in its own right under rule 20.3, so the claimant must file a defence to it within the usual period or risk default judgment on the counterclaim under Part 12. The claimant doesn't need to file an acknowledgment of service to a counterclaim; rule 20.4(3) removes that step.
Can a counterclaim be larger than the claim?
Yes. There's no rule that a counterclaim must be smaller than, or related in size to, the original claim. Where a counterclaim is for more than £10,000, the court looks at both figures when allocating the case to a track, and the whole case may move off the small claims track to the fast track or intermediate track.
What is the difference between a counterclaim and a set-off?
A set-off is a defence: it says the claimant's claim should be reduced by a sum the defendant is owed, so that only the balance, if any, is payable. A counterclaim is a separate claim that can produce a judgment in the defendant's favour for more than the claim was worth. Many defences plead both, with the set-off as a shield and the counterclaim as a sword.
Can my employer counterclaim against me in the employment tribunal?
Only in limited circumstances. An employer can bring an employer's contract claim under the Employment Tribunals Extension of Jurisdiction (England and Wales) Order 1994, but only if you have first brought a breach of contract claim yourself, your employment has ended, and the employer includes its claim in its ET3 response within the response deadline (rule 24 of the Employment Tribunal Procedure Rules 2024). The tribunal can't award more than £25,000 on a contract claim. An employer can't counterclaim in response to an unfair dismissal or discrimination claim alone.
What a counterclaim is, and what it is not
When a defendant receives a claim form, the defence can do three different things. It can deny the claim. It can say the claim should be reduced by money the claimant owes the defendant, which is a set-off. Or it can go further and ask the court to order the claimant to pay the defendant: that is a counterclaim. The Civil Procedure Rules group counterclaims with other “additional claims” in Part 20, and rule 20.3 says an additional claim is treated as a claim for most purposes.
The practical consequences follow from that. The defendant pays a fee to bring it. The claimant must file a defence to it. If the claimant does not, the defendant can ask for default judgment on the counterclaim. And at the hearing the judge decides both the claim and the counterclaim, which may result in one net sum being payable by whichever side owes more.
How and when to make a counterclaim
- 1 With the defence. Rule 20.4(2)(a) lets a defendant counterclaim against the claimant without permission if the counterclaim is filed with the defence. On a county court money claim the defence and counterclaim form (N9B, or the online equivalent) has a section for it.
- 2 Later, with permission. If the moment has passed, rule 20.4(2)(b) requires an application to the court for permission, usually on an N244 with a fee.
- 3 Against someone else. A counterclaim against a person who isn't yet a party needs an application under rule 20.5 to add them, which can be made without notice unless the court directs otherwise.
- 4 Pay the fee. A money counterclaim carries the same issue fee as a claim for that amount under the EX50 schedule. The court won't process the counterclaim until the fee or a help with fees application is received.
The particulars of the counterclaim should read like particulars of claim: what the claimant did or failed to do, what loss it caused, and the sum claimed, with interest if it's sought. It must be verified by a statement of truth.
The claimant becomes, for the purposes of the counterclaim, a defendant. Rule 20.4(3) removes the need for an acknowledgment of service, but a defence to counterclaim must still be filed within the normal period. Rule 20.3(3) applies Part 12, so a claimant who ignores the counterclaim risks default judgment on it.
The court then allocates the whole case to a track. Rule 26.13(1)(e) makes the value of any counterclaim, and the complexity of the matters it raises, one of the things the court must consider when deciding the track, so a large counterclaim can pull a small claim onto the fast track, with the different costs consequences that brings. Both sides then follow the same directions, exchange documents and witness statements, and attend one hearing at which the judge decides everything.
Limitation works in the defendant's favour here. Section 35(1)(b) of the Limitation Act 1980 deems a new claim made in the course of an action, including a counterclaim, to have been commenced on the same date as the original action, and section 35(3) allows an “original” counterclaim, one made by a party who hasn't previously claimed in the action, even where its own limitation period has since expired. The counterclaim must, however, have been in time on the date the claimant issued the claim form.
The employment tribunal version: the employer's contract claim
The employment tribunal has no general counterclaim. What it has is the employer's contract claim under the Employment Tribunals Extension of Jurisdiction (England and Wales) Order 1994. Article 4 of the Order allows an employer to claim against an employee only where the employee has already brought a contract claim in the tribunal, and the employer's claim arose or was outstanding when the employment ended. The tribunal can't award more than £25,000 on contract claims under article 10, and certain types of claim are outside the tribunal's contract jurisdiction altogether: personal injury claims (section 3(3) of the Employment Tribunals Act 1996) and claims about the terms listed in article 5 of the Order, which cover living accommodation, intellectual property, confidentiality and restrictive covenants.
Rule 24 of the Employment Tribunal Procedure Rules 2024 requires the employer to include its contract claim in its ET3 response, filed within the response deadline. The claimant then replies under rule 26. Because the right depends on the employee having started a contract claim, an employee who claims only unfair dismissal or discrimination can't be met with an employer's contract claim at all. That is worth knowing before adding a small notice pay claim to an ET1 where the employer believes it's owed money, for example for unreturned equipment or a training-cost repayment clause.
A kitchen fitter sues a homeowner for £4,200, the unpaid balance of his invoice. The homeowner says the work was defective and that she has paid £2,600 to another tradesperson to put it right. She files a defence denying that the balance is due and a counterclaim for the £2,600 remedial cost.
Fee to issue the counterclaim (EX50, £1,500.01–£3,000 band)
Judge's finding: fitter owed, after allowing for defects
Judge's finding: homeowner's remedial cost recoverable
Net judgment in favour of the fitter
The judge gives judgment on both the claim and the counterclaim and orders the homeowner to pay the net difference. Had the remedial cost been found to be £3,500, the net judgment would have gone the other way and the fitter would have been paying.
Civil Procedure Rules, Part 20
Employment Tribunal Procedure Rules 2024 (SI 2024/1155)
Employment Tribunals Extension of Jurisdiction (England and Wales) Order 1994 (SI 1994/1623)
EX50 — civil and family court fees
Counterclaim — Small Claims Glossary
What a counterclaim is, how a defendant makes one under CPR Part 20, the fee and deadlines involved, and how the employment tribunal's employer's contract claim differs.