Costs order
An order that one party pays another's costs. On the small claims track and in the employment tribunal the starting point is that each side bears its own, so a costs order is the exception, not the rule.
If I win my small claim, does the other side pay my solicitor's bill?
Almost never. Rule 27.14 of the Civil Procedure Rules stops the court ordering one side to pay the other's legal costs on the small claims track, apart from a short list of exceptions. What a winning party can normally recover is the court fees they paid, the fixed costs attached to issuing the claim, reasonable travel expenses to the hearing, up to £95 a day for loss of earnings or leave for each person attending, and up to £750 for an expert's fee where the court gave permission for expert evidence. A solicitor's bill for preparing the case isn't on that list.
What counts as unreasonable behaviour for a small claims costs order?
The rules do not define it, and judges apply it case by case. Examples that have led to costs orders include pursuing a claim or defence with no real basis, ignoring court orders, failing to turn up to a hearing without explanation, and conduct designed to run up the other side's costs. Rule 27.14(3) says that turning down a settlement offer isn't in itself unreasonable, although the court can take the refusal into account when it looks at the whole picture.
Can an employment tribunal order me to pay the employer's costs?
It can, but it's rare. Under rule 74 of the Employment Tribunal Procedure Rules 2024 the tribunal must consider costs where a party has acted vexatiously, abusively, disruptively or otherwise unreasonably, where a claim or response had no reasonable prospect of success, or where a hearing is postponed on a late application. Even then the tribunal has a discretion, and rule 82 says it may take the paying party's ability to pay into account. Tribunal statistics consistently show costs orders in a very small fraction of cases.
How much can an employment tribunal costs order be?
Rule 76 of the Employment Tribunal Procedure Rules 2024 lets the tribunal order a specified sum of up to £20,000 without any formal assessment. Larger amounts are possible, but only where the costs are assessed in detail by a county court or by the tribunal applying the same principles, or where the parties agree the figure. Witness expenses can also be ordered separately.
What is a preparation time order?
It's the employment tribunal's equivalent of a costs order for a party who had no lawyer. Instead of legal fees, it compensates the time the party spent preparing the case, at an hourly rate set by rule 77 of the 2024 Rules. The same triggers in rule 74 apply, and a tribunal can't make both a costs order and a preparation time order in favour of the same party for the same proceedings.
Does a costs order include the court fee I paid?
On the small claims track, yes: rule 27.14(2)(c) allows the court to order the losing party to pay any court fees the winning party paid, including the issue fee and the hearing fee. The judge normally deals with this at the end of the hearing. If you want it, ask for it, and have the figures to hand.
Why costs work differently in small claims
In most civil litigation the loser pays the winner's reasonable legal costs. The small claims track was designed to be different. Because claims are worth £10,000 or less and most parties represent themselves, rule 27.14 of the Civil Procedure Rules switches off the general costs-shifting rule and replaces it with a closed list. Unless one of the exceptions applies, the court “may not order a party to pay a sum to another party in respect of that other party's costs, fees and expenses”.
What a small claims costs order can include
Rule 27.14(2) lists what the court may order. In a typical money claim the items that matter are:
- 1 Court fees. The issue fee and the hearing fee the winning party paid (rule 27.14(2)(c)). This is usually the largest item.
- 2 Fixed costs on issue. A modest fixed sum attached to issuing the claim, calculated from Table 2 in Practice Direction 45 and already shown on the claim form (rule 27.14(2)(a)).
- 3 Travel and loss of earnings. Expenses a party or witness reasonably incurred travelling to and from the hearing, and up to £95 a day for each person for loss of earnings or leave (rule 27.14(2)(d) and (e), PD 27A paragraph 7.3).
- 4 Expert fees. Up to £750 for each expert, and only where the court gave permission for expert evidence in the first place (rule 27.14(2)(f)).
- 5 Legal help in injunction claims. Where the claim includes an injunction or specific performance, up to £260 for legal help with that claim (rule 27.14(2)(b), PD 27A paragraph 7.2).
The court also has the power in rule 27.14(2)(g) to order further costs, assessed summarily, against a party who has behaved unreasonably. This is the one route by which a small claims party can end up paying something like real legal costs, and it's used sparingly.
The unreasonable behaviour exception
The word “unreasonably” is not defined in the rules. Judges look at the conduct of the proceedings as a whole and ask whether the party crossed the line between fighting a case hard and misusing the process. Pursuing a claim that was plainly bound to fail, failing to comply with directions, not attending the hearing, or dragging in matters that have nothing to do with the dispute are the kind of conduct that has attracted orders.
Rule 27.14(3) adds one specific point: rejecting an offer to settle isn't of itself unreasonable, but the court may take the rejection into account when it applies the test. So a party who refuses a sensible offer and then recovers less than it at the hearing isn't automatically penalised, but has given the judge something to weigh.
The same limits apply to the fees of a lay representative (rule 27.14(4)). A friend who charges to speak for you at the hearing can't have that charge recovered from the other side outside the listed exceptions.
Costs orders in the employment tribunal
The employment tribunal is also a costs-neutral forum by default, but its rules are framed differently. Under rule 74 of the Employment Tribunal Procedure Rules 2024 the tribunal must consider making a costs order or a preparation time order where a party or their representative has acted vexatiously, abusively, disruptively or otherwise unreasonably in bringing or conducting the proceedings, where a claim, response or reply had no reasonable prospect of success, or where a hearing was postponed or adjourned on an application made less than 7 days before it. It may make one where a party has breached an order, rule or practice direction, or where a hearing is postponed for any reason.
Considering costs isn't the same as ordering them. The tribunal then decides whether to make an order at all, and if so how much. Rule 76 allows a specified amount of up to £20,000 without a detailed assessment; higher figures require assessment or agreement. Rule 82 lets the tribunal take the paying party's ability to pay into account at both stages. Rule 81 and rule 76(1)(c) deal separately with witness expenses.
A respondent will sometimes write a “costs warning” letter early in a claim, saying the claim is hopeless and costs will be sought if it continues. Such a letter doesn't itself create any liability. It becomes relevant only if the tribunal later finds the claim did have no reasonable prospect of success, and even then the tribunal has to be persuaded that an order is appropriate.
How to ask for costs
In a small claim, raise it at the end of the hearing once the judge has given judgment. Bring a short written note of the items you're claiming: fee receipts, a note of mileage or train fares, and a line for loss of earnings with evidence of your daily pay. The judge will deal with it in minutes if the figures are clear. In the employment tribunal, rule 75 allows an application at any stage up to 28 days after the judgment is sent, and the tribunal must give the other party a reasonable opportunity to respond before deciding.
A claimant sues a trader for £2,400 for a faulty boiler installation. The trader defends, the case is listed for a small claims hearing, and the claimant wins in full. She took a day of unpaid leave to attend, drove 30 miles each way, and had earlier paid the issue fee and the hearing fee for a claim in the £1,500.01 to £3,000 band.
Issue fee recovered (rule 27.14(2)(c))
Hearing fee recovered (rule 27.14(2)(c))
Fixed costs on issue (PD 45 Table 2, as shown on the N1)
as stated on the claim form
Loss of a day's pay (capped at £95)
Mileage at a reasonable rate
Costs and expenses ordered, before fixed costs
Her actual loss of pay for the day was £140, but the PD 27A limit holds it at £95. Had she instructed a solicitor for £900 to prepare the case, none of that would be recoverable unless the trader had behaved unreasonably.
Civil Procedure Rules, Part 27
Practice Direction 27A
Employment Tribunal Procedure Rules 2024 (SI 2024/1155)
EX50 — civil and family court fees
Costs Order — Small Claims and Tribunal Glossary
What a costs order is, the strict limits on costs in the small claims track under CPR 27.14, and when an employment tribunal can order costs under the 2024 Rules.